The Spartan Scroll

The Student News Site of Rosemont Middle School

The Spartan Scroll

The Spartan Scroll

Book Review – Murtagh

Book Review - Murtagh
John Jude Palencar

In 2002, Christopher Paolini published his first novel, Eragon. He started working on this novel when he was sixteen. The book follows the farm boy, Eragon, who finds a dragon egg in the forest and is whisked away on an epic adventure to defeat the evil king, Galbatorix. Since then, The Inheritance Cycle has become an international bestseller with four lengthy yet engaging books. In 2006, Eragon was adapted into an ill-fated film, and is currently being made into a Disney live-action series. However, after the release of The Fork, the Witch, and the Worm, an additional book in the series, fans thought that the Inheritance Cycle was over for good.
All of this changed, however, when Paolini announced that he was returning to Alagaesia with a new addition to the world of Eragon. Murtagh was released on November 7th, 2023, following a fan-favorite character, Murtagh and his dragon a year after the events of Inheritance, where they are left to face the trauma and consequences of being controlled by Galbatorix. A new threat is arising in Alagaesia, and Murtagh and his dragon Thorn will have to face these dangers alone and conquer their fears to save the land they love.
If I had to choose, I would give this book four stars. The characters are extremely well-developed and believable, and Paolini does an amazing job at encapturing the trauma they are experiencing. The relationship between dragon and rider is one of the most charming things about The Inheritance Cycle. Murtagh and Thorn maintain that quality while still having a completely different and original relationship than the riders and dragons from the Inheritance Cycle. The new society introduced in Murtagh was fascinating and added a sort of dystopian element to the novel, and the villain, a witch named Bachel, was powerful and terrifying. Murtagh is a book with amazing character development, and it will not disappoint fans of the original series.
However, Murtagh still has its flaws. Christopher Paolini has shown one weakness throughout almost all of his books: they are too long. Murtagh can be slow and boring at times, and it takes a very long time to even arrive at the main setting of the story. There are a few parts that just seem to drag on way too long, and you just find yourself skimming through. However, this story is still very enjoyable, and as you reach the end you will feel very satisfied and excited for the next part of Murtagh’s story. Overall, Murtagh is the perfect book for lovers of high fantasy and dragons, and I would strongly recommend it.

Story continues below advertisement
View Comments (2)
Donate to The Spartan Scroll
$665
$1500
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation will support the student journalists of Rosemont Middle School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment, take field trips, and cover our annual website costs.

Navigate Left
Navigate Right
About the Contributor
Josephine Gaudioso
Josephine Gaudioso, Senior Arts and Culture Editor
Josephine (Jojo) Gaudioso is thirteen years old and grew up in La Crescenta, where she attended Franklin Elementary School and learned Italian for seven years. She lives with her parents and two siblings and likes to read and write fantasy stories. She also plays piano and guitar and enjoys listening to music from the 80s and 90s. Jojo is an eighth grader at Rosemont and a Senior Arts and Culture Editor for the Spartan Scroll. When she grows up she wants to be an author and have at least two pets.
Donate to The Spartan Scroll
$665
$1500
Contributed
Our Goal

Comments (2)

All The Spartan Scroll Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • F

    FergJan 27, 2024 at 8:52 am

    Before i started reading the novel i had one concern. When we last left eragon we were in a state of peace, they had just killed galbatorix, the varden had taken control over the empire, eragon and saphira were now protecting the eggs, and murtagh and thorn had gone off to heal themselves and recover from their trauma.

    The book continues in a time of peace and i kept thinking what is their main objective? Why are they doing what theyre doing? Granted i appreciate the story being one of self recovery but not having an actual antagonist until three quarters through a rather long book?

    The book is enjoyable but i dont think id give it a second read as i have with all the others of the series. 3 out of 5 stars

    Reply
    • J

      JojoFeb 1, 2024 at 10:40 am

      I do agree that they took a very long time to discover who the antagonist was, and have to face a real threat. However, there was an antagonist and a main conflict the entire time, it just took a long time for them to discover who it was.

      Reply